5

CVE-2020-1685

Junos OS: EX4600, QFX5K Series: Stateless firewall filter matching 'user-vlan-id' will cause incomplete discard action

When configuring stateless firewall filters in Juniper Networks EX4600 and QFX 5000 Series devices using Virtual Extensible LAN protocol (VXLAN), the discard action will fail to discard traffic under certain conditions. Given a firewall filter configuration similar to: family ethernet-switching { filter L2-VLAN { term ALLOW { from { user-vlan-id 100; } then { accept; } } term NON-MATCH { then { discard; } } when there is only one term containing a 'user-vlan-id' match condition, and no other terms in the firewall filter except discard, the discard action for non-matching traffic will only discard traffic with the same VLAN ID specified under 'user-vlan-id'. Other traffic (e.g. VLAN ID 200) will not be discarded. This unexpected behavior can lead to unintended traffic passing through the interface where the firewall filter is applied. This issue only affects systems using VXLANs. This issue affects Juniper Networks Junos OS on QFX5K Series: 18.1 versions prior to 18.1R3-S7, except 18.1R3; 18.2 versions prior to 18.2R2-S7, 18.2R3-S1; 18.3 versions prior to 18.3R1-S5, 18.3R2-S4, 18.3R3; 18.4 versions prior to 18.4R1-S7, 18.4R2-S1, 18.4R3; 19.1 versions prior to 19.1R1-S5, 19.1R2; 19.2 versions prior to 19.2R1-S5, 19.2R2.
Daten sind bereitgestellt durch National Vulnerability Database (NVD)
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r2-s1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r2-s2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r2-s4
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r3-s1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r3-s2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r3-s3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r3-s4
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.1 Update r3-s6
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r1 Edition -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r1-s3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r1-s4
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r1-s5
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r2-s1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r2-s2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r2-s3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r2-s4
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r2-s5
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r2-s6
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.2 Update r3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r1-s1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r1-s2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r1-s3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r1-s4
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r2-s1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r2-s2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.3 Update r2-s3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update r1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update r1-s1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update r1-s2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update r1-s3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update r1-s4
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update r1-s5
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update r1-s6
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 18.4 Update r2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.1 Update -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.1 Update r1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.1 Update r1-s1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.1 Update r1-s2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.1 Update r1-s3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.1 Update r1-s4
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.2 Update -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.2 Update r1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.2 Update r1-s1
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.2 Update r1-s2
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.2 Update r1-s3
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Juniper ≫ Junos Version 19.2 Update r1-s4
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5100 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5110 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5120 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5130 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5200 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5210 Version -
   Juniper ≫ Qfx5220 Version -
Zu dieser CVE wurde keine Warnung gefunden.
EPSS Metriken
Typ Quelle Score Percentile
EPSS FIRST.org 0.76% 0.51
CVSS Metriken
Quelle Base Score Exploit Score Impact Score Vector String
NIST 5 10 2.9
AV:N/AC:L/Au:N/C:N/I:P/A:N
Juniper 5.8 3.9 1.4
CVSS:3.1/AV:N/AC:L/PR:N/UI:N/S:C/C:N/I:L/A:N
CWE-203 Observable Discrepancy

The product behaves differently or sends different responses under different circumstances in a way that is observable to an unauthorized actor.